From our work helping clients understand and manage their reputational equity and risk, our reputation management team has identified a number of best practices in reputation measurement. Reputational effects of operational risk events for financial. From these, the report identifies the following principal. Fombrun executive director reputation institute henley management college. Linking the identification and assessment of reputational risk to the instruments used for. Reputation risk is driven by a wide range of other business that must all be actively managed. Managing and measuring reputational risk can be more elusive than managing operational risk or credit risk, according to merrie spaeth, president and founder of spaeth communications. Reputational risk will often come hand in hand with operational risk, but it has yet to be taken as seriously, if it is even considered at all.
Understanding what reputational risk is boardeffect. Quantifying and managing reputation risk has become more difficult. Download pdf measuring operational and reputational risk. Operational risk includes concerns about such issues as transaction processing errors, liability situations, and backoffice failure. As a result, the realm of reputational risk is now regarded as a meta risk for companies, standing at the forefront of any key strategic and operational concern for global and middle eastern senior executives. Academic and business thinking about this subject continues to evolve.
Reputation risk management involves more than just effective communication. Businessoperational risk relates to activities carried out within an entity, arising. Reputation risk is closely related to operational risks including legal and is not always possible to separate them. Pdf assessing corporate reputational damage of data. Reputation risk is measured within the scope of significant business processes and identification of significant risks. Our proposed measurement technique quantifies reputation risk and provides. Measuring reputation and reputation risk, is however, a difficult task, in part because of the many. Approaches to measuring, limiting and managing risks, especially those facing small. By operational risk, i mean primarily the risk of loss from internal control breakdowns. Learning objectives operational risk data measuring operational risk loss events key risk indicators subjective risk assessments top down approaches bottomup approaches managing operational risk developing an appropriate risk management environment risk identification, assessment, monitoring and control.
Principles for the sound management of operational risk bis. Pdf corporate strategies have been increasingly confronted with the need. Basel committee on banking supervision consultative. Reputation risk is measured by the risk assessment working group of. Measuring reputational risk in the south african banking sector sune ferreira 23261048 dissertation submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree. Click download or read online button to measuring operational and reputational risk book pdf for free now. As discussed in the committees paper operational risk supervisory guidelines for the advanced. The initial reputationbrand of a firm was an important factor driving the loss, with the reputation risk losses more than. Mastering operational risk download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl. Companies should start investing to improve their capabilities for managing reputation risk. Measuring and managing reputational risk by daniel. Its important to develop a framework for managing reputational risk prior to an issue. Companies should be fully aware of their exposure to reputation risk.
On the other hand, companies may suffer reputational damage that can result from internal or external and potentially unforeseen events such as operational losses. Attempts to quantify reputational risk rigorously are fraught with difficulty. Reputational risk has now become a potential threat on a par. The number of reputational risk events occurring is large the impact of some reputational risk events can be devastating, and 54% of institutions state that they do not have the ability to withstand a major reputational risk event. The second hypothesis focuses on the question of reputational risk associated with operational loss events. The aim of this paper is to fill this gap by assessing the consequences of operational risk for a financial firm including reputational losses. Rethinking reputational risk explains the hidden factors which can both cause crises and tip an otherwise survivable crisis into a reputational disaster. Measuring operational and reputational risk by aldo soprano. Deutsche bank annual report 2016 reputational risk. While operational risk has been receiving significant attention by regulators for more than a decade, incidents such as the exceptional loss at societe generale of almost five billion euro in 2008 caused by the trader jerome kerviel once more spurred the interest paid to operational risk by regulators, supervisors, bank executives, and the public. A 2015 global risk management survey by the riskmanagement consulting firm aon plc found that damage to reputation or brand was ranked by corporations as their numberone risk, moving up from number four in 20. Hence, an indirect way of measuring a reputational event is to estimate the impact of a loss announcement on a.
Based on extensive applied research on operational risk models using real bank datasets, it offers a wide range of various testing models and fitting techniques for financial practitioners. Reputational risk management in financial institutions. The following steps will help you measure, monitor, manage and mitigate damage to your reputation. Reputation risk is measured by the risk assessment working group of experts on the. Mastering operational risk download ebook pdf, epub. Measuring operational and reputational risk wiley online books. Approaches to measuring, limiting and managing risks. October 2005 please do not quote without permission abstract we measure reputational losses by examining a. The use of scenarios can help companies gauge the potential magnitude of incidents and identify mitigation opportunities. Banks have some focus on self assessments in that regard. In addition to external relations activities, it requires the. Reputational risk can be a difficult term to understand because its difficult to define. Measuring operational and reputational risk by aldo.
Measuring operational and reputational risk overdrive. Toping the list are risks related to ethics and integrity, such as fraud, bribery, and corruption. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. How to measure the reputational risk of your business. Effective management of reputational risk should be based on systematic identification and assessment of material risk. A practitioner s guide maps out the process of risk assessment and mitigation undertaken by risk managers at unicredit group in response to the requirements of the basel ii accord. Abstract we measure reputational losses by examining a. Therefore in 2001, the pnc financial services group recommended a more concise definition for the operational risk, a definition that should be based more on direct losses and which exclude categorical the business risk, the strategic risk and the reputational risk. Modelling operational and reputational risks shows practitioners the best models to use in a given situation, according to the type of risk an organization is facing. In this paper, we present an empirical analysis of how. Reputational risk is the potential that negative publicity regarding an institutions.
Consequently, reputational risk is arguably the worst type of risk a financial institution is exposed to. Reputational risk has now become a potential threat on a par with new competition, technology failures, talent. Corporate reputational risk and enterprise risk management. The 97 survey questions were informed by the recent cro forum1 white paper, principles of operational risk management and measurement september 20142. Measuring reputational risk in the south african banking sector. A companys reputation is one of its most valuable assets, and reputational risk is high on the agenda at board level and amongst regulators. Of these, credit risk and operational risk are the most important at. In the third and fourth sections has been introduced the concept of reputational risk according to the enterprise risk. Corporate reputation represents a core asset of companies and research has shown that better reputation can have positive effects such as increased revenues and sales.
Basel committee on banking supervision consultative document. How to apply operational risk theory to reallife banking data modelling operational and reputational risks shows practitioners the best models to use in a given. Defining reputationalbrand risk is hard to accomplish. Mar 26, 2018 reputational risk can be a difficult term to understand because its difficult to define. Operational risk and reputation in financial institutions. We find that market values fall oneforone with losses caused by external events. Modeling operational risk incorporating reputation risk fau.
Measuring operational and reputational risk download measuring operational and reputational risk ebook pdf or read online books in pdf, epub, and mobi format. Measuring and modelling operational risk focuses on the measuring and modelling techniques banks and investment companies need to quantify operational risk and provides practical, sensible solutions for doing so. The objective of the survey was to understand the current practices in. It is one of occs eight categories of risk covered in its largebank supervision handbook, for example. The market reaction to operational loss announcements. The initial reputationbrand of a firm was an important factor driving the loss, with the reputation risk losses more than doubling when an event happens to a firm with a strong brand. Measuring operational and reputational risk wiley online. Click download or read online button to get mastering operational risk book now. Based on some additional research done by my colleague sylvesto lorello, reputational risk is not a new concept, but it arguably has no established or universally agreed upon definition. Even executives with sophisticated and smart market research portfolios find themselves asking, how do you measure corporate reputation. Modeling operational risk incorporating reputation risk.
Aug 19, 2016 into account when modeling and assessing operational risk. Apr 15, 2019 reputational risk is a threat or danger to the good name or standing of a business or entity. Based on extensive applied research on operational risk models using real bank datasets, it offers a wide range of various testing models and fitting techniques for. You bring it up frequently with people across the organization and have tried to figure out how in the world. Measuring reputational risk in the south african banking sector sune ferreira 23261048 dissertation submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree magister commercii in risk management at the vaal triangle campus of the northwest university. Reputational risk can occur through a number of ways. To be able to measure these financial reputational losses, we.
Reputational risk is the risk of damaging the institutions trustworthiness in the marketplace. Measuring reputational risk in the south african banking. As the person representing erm at your organization, reputation risk is likely at the top of the list of concerns. The objective of the survey was to understand the current practices in operational risk management in. Measuring and managing reputational risk by daniel diermeier reputational risk w page 20 risk management w march 2008 daniel diermeier is the ibm distinguished professor of regulation and competitive practice and a professor of managerial economics and decision sciences at the kellogg graduate school of management, northwestern university. If the firms market value declines by more than the announced loss amount, this is interpreted as a reputational loss. That will help you determine public perception of your company and competitors as well as the industry in which you operate.
Defining reputational risk risk management monitor. Operational and reputational risk in the european banking industry. Issues of governance and management of reputational risk are not the subject of this paper. Reputational risk represents a more elusive risk category with respect to market, credit and operational risk, because of the difficulty in quantifying its effects and above all in understanding of the mechanisms that generate it. We find that market values fall oneforone with losses caused by external events, but fall by over twice the loss percentage in cases involving. Of these, credit risk and operational risk are the most important at small and mediumsized institutions in the united states. Toward this endwe, extend current operational risk models by incorporating reputation losses. David benyon finds out why, and asks what might be done to resolve this situation. For example, the conference board 2007 suggests that not. Operational risks and reputation risks are now part of managements focus in examining the total enterprise risk. We measure reputational losses by examining a firms stock price reaction to the announcement of a major operational loss event.
Identifying the specific reputational component, as distinct from the credit, market, or operational risks, will require internal principles for its identification to avoid wanton results or capital overcharges. The shortterm effect of reputation risk events on sales and profits can be significant in. Within our risk management process, we define reputational risk as the risk of possible damage to our brand and reputation, and the associated risk to earnings, capital or liquidity, arising from any association, action or inaction which could be perceived by stakeholders to be inappropriate, unethical or inconsistent with dbs values and beliefs. A practitioners approach reputational risk is the potential that negative publicity regarding an institutions business practices, whether true or not, will cause a decline in the customer base, costly litigation or revenue reductions. Consequently, the scope of the framework presented in this paper focuses primarily upon the operational risk component of other risks and encourages the industry to further develop techniques for measuring, monitoring and mitigating operational risk. Managing reputational risk measuring operational and. For those engaged in risk management, reputational risk has increased in importance in recent years. How to apply operational risk theory to reallife banking datamodelling operational and reputational risks shows practitioners the best models to use in a given. Defining reputational brand risk is hard to accomplish. In this chapter we will look more closely at reputational risk and the ways that an operational risk framework can be leveraged to help identify, assess, control, and mitigate reputational risk.
However, financial firms are unavoidably subject to reputational risk as a result of the. Operational and reputational risk in the european banking. How to apply operational risk theory to reallife banking data modelling operational and reputational risks shows practitioners the best models to use in a given situation, according to the type of risk an organization is facing. How to apply operational risk theory to reallife banking datamodelling operational and reputational risks shows practitioners the best models to use in a given situation, according to the type of risk an organization is facing. Strategic and reputational risk is not included in this definition for the purpose of a minimum regulatory operational risk capital charge. Learning objectives operational risk data measuring operational risk loss events key risk indicators subjective risk assessments top down approaches bottomup approaches managing operational risk developing an appropriate risk management environment risk identification, assessment, monitoring and control management of. We do not attempt to distinguish among the thirdparties that may be. Applying the methodology to operational risk events in the financial services. Step one is to execute a reputational risk assessment to establish the baseline for your companys image. Percentage of respondents by insurer type general 27% composite 30% life 43% most eu insurers in the survey 68% are applying for use of an internal model to calculate operational risk capital under solvency ii where relevant, with the remaining. Techniques from operational risk are used to estimate salesprofit changes for normal unstressed business operations, and also in stressed conditions using valueatrisk var. Pdf two principal results for reputation risk are established. Reputation has become an increasingly wellunderstood issue for boards and executives with regulatory pressure increasing to demonstrate the measures taken to understand and engage with stakeholders.
1312 976 1204 506 32 529 1271 1595 81 1438 1574 1300 1620 993 775 214 1486 1560 1592 501 500 1247 453 1516 1434 1462 1146 1224 1577 1622 749 982 192 647 108 241 540 702 1437 840 921 471